Agenda and draft minutes

Health and Wellbeing Board - Wednesday 7 September 2022 1.30 pm

Venue: Committee Room 2, Shire Hall. View directions

Contact: Paul Spencer  Senior Democratic Services Officer

Media

Items
No. Item

1.

General

Additional documents:

1(1)

Apologies

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Apologies for absence had been received from Councillor Jeff Morgan (WCC), Russell Hardy (SWFT and George Eliot Hospital NHS Trust), Dame Stella Manzieand Justine Richards (UHCW), Jagtar Singh(Coventry and Warwickshire Partnership Trust (viewing the meeting on-line)), Councillor Julian Gutteridge (Nuneaton and Bedworth Borough Council), Councillor Howard Roberts (Rugby Borough Council), Danielle Oum and Phil Johns (Coventry and Warwickshire Integrated Care System (ICS)).

1(2)

Appointment of Vice-Chair

The Board is asked to appoint a Vice-Chair.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The Chair advised that it was proposed to speak to the ICS regarding non-executive representation for the position of Vice-Chair. Other nominations from the Board would similarly be considered and this matter be revisited at the January Board meeting.

1(3)

Members' Disclosures of Pecuniary and Non-Pecuniary Interests

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Councillor Jerry Roodhouse declared an interest as a Director of Healthwatch Warwickshire. Councillor Falp declared a personal interest in the item on the Health Visiting Service.

1(4)

Minutes of the Meeting of the Warwickshire Health and Wellbeing Board on 4 May and Matters Arising pdf icon PDF 140 KB

Draft minutes of the previous meeting held on 4 May 2022 are attached for approval.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The minutes of the Board meeting held on 4 May 2022 were approved as a true record and signed by the Chair.

 

As a matter arising, Councillor Roodhouse sought an update regarding discussions with the West Midlands Ambulance Service (WMAS). Nigel Minns provided a verbal update. There had been lengthy discussions about engagement with WMAS at the Integrated Care Board (ICB) and good progress had been made. WMAS were regular attendees at an Urgent and Emergency Care Board, also attended by WCC, so there was an ongoing dialogue. Particular areas being discussed were delayed ambulance transfers, hospital waits and the balance of risk around people waiting either in an ambulance or a hospital corridor. He spoke further about urgent non-emergency (category 3) cases, conveyancing aspects, response to falls, frailty and a directory of services to provide other options to emergency admission. The Chair asked for regular updates to be provided. Councillor Humphreys raised a concern for patients with dementia who were delayed in an ambulance awaiting hospital handover. It was agreed that WMAS be asked to permit dementia patients to be accompanied when such waits occurred.

1(5)

Chair's Announcements

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The Chair gave an update on the Children and Young People Partnership Board. An initial scoping meeting took place at the end of July, the draft terms of reference had been produced and its first meeting would take place in late September. Periodic reports would be provided back to this Board.

 

The first formal meeting of the Integrated Care Partnership (ICP) took place on 26th July. The two Health and Wellbeing Board Chairs for Coventry and Warwickshire had been appointed as joint deputy chairs. The Partnership had agreed its terms of reference and ways of working together in alliance.  The ICP had started to develop its Integrated Care Strategy, which would include engagement with Healthwatch and others. The Chair spoke of the progress made to date by a strategy development working group and the plans to discuss this further at the Integrated Health and Wellbeing Forum on 13 October.

 

The Chair asked for brevity in presentations due to the weight of the Agenda and to enable adequate discussion.

2.

Adult Social Care Reforms pdf icon PDF 159 KB

The Health and Wellbeing Board is asked to consider and comment upon the programme of work underway to support Adult Social Care Reform in Warwickshire.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The Health and Wellbeing Board received a presentation from Pete Sidgwick, Assistant Director for Adult Social Care. This summarised the current requirements and progress to deliver adult social care reform in Warwickshire with a focus on the care cap, Fair Cost of Care (FCoC) and Care Quality Commission (CQC) oversight.  Health and social care integration was not a focus for this presentation but remained a priority, as evidenced through the joint working and development of the Coventry and Warwickshire Integrated Care System.

 

The work programme provided a consolidated and joined up response to the objectives, key features and requirements of Government policies/white papers relating to adult social care reforms: 

 

·       Build-back-better: Our plan for health and social care Sept 21 & Jan 2022 update 

·       "People at the heart of care" adult social care reform white paper 

·       Market Sustainability and Fair Cost of Care Fund

·       Health and Care Integration - Joining up care for people, places and populations  

 

The presentation expanded on the key messages with slides on:

·       Adult Social Care Government Policy Reforms

·       General points:

o   High level ‘indications’ lacking detail

o   Multiple aspirations being articulated amongst requirements

o   A landscape which doesn’t keep to timescales

o   Lots of national, regional and local ‘views’

o   A number of significant financial implications within the reforms without the clarity on funding streams

o   Questions if the pace of delivery is realistic

·       The overarching approach and officer leads.

·       CQC oversight (People at the Heart of Care)

·       Cost of Care Cap (Build Back Better)

 

Debate took place on the following areas:

 

·       The Chair recognised the considerable work underway to respond to these changes and significant implications of them.

·       Points about packages of care following hospital discharge. The benefits of rehabilitation in step-down care and ensuring that all required equipment was provided in a timely way, as this benefitted patients significantly. It was confirmed that the County Council administered the discharge to assess pathway on behalf of health and the approach taken was considered to be correct, with support out of hospital. The involvement of the CQC was also considered to be the right thing to do with regulation likely to drive improvements, hearing the customer voice and a focus on carers. There had been a step change in hospital discharge, and it was expected that the number of people being supported would increase. The challenges would remain going into the winter period.

·       A request for regular information to be provided to the County Council Network (CCN) and Local Government Association (LGA). The CCN was considering this area in detail. The proposed timescales were considered to be unrealistic with delays being sought, not least due to government ministerial changes. The cost elements were raised and potential impact for care home viability questioned. There was variance amongst local authorities of the percentage costs being used and submitted to the government as part of this process. It was confirmed there was a continuous dialogue and information sharing took place with the CCN, LGA and County Council Treasurers. The challenges  ...  view the full minutes text for item 2.

3.

Health Visiting Paper pdf icon PDF 183 KB

This item provides an update on the Health Visiting Service, detailing the best practice and innovation, the issues and challenges faced and it seeks the Board’s support for proposed actions.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The Board received a comprehensive update and presentation on the 0-5 Health Visiting Service (HVS) from Rob Sabin, WCC commissioner and Sarah Foster, Deputy General Manager for 0-5 HVS, SWFT.

 

Background was provided on the role of the service to protect and promote the health and wellbeing of children and their families through the delivery of the nationally mandated Healthy Child Programme (0-5). The HVS was key to delivering the Warwickshire Health and Wellbeing Strategy priority around helping children and young people to have the best start in life. The current service was delivered by SWFT, with the contract due to expire on 31 March 2023.

 

A summary was provided of service performance.  This service met a wide spectrum of needs for all children (birth to five) within Warwickshire, with some key areas that delivered more targeted needs. The service continued to innovate and adapt its practice, with examples being provided. Developmental reviews and checks were mandated, and contract performance was monitored against five HV mandated contact performance indicators. The provider's performance in this area had declined with tables providing data to demonstrate this.

 

The report then set out the identified service issues and challenges. It included challenges around recruitment and retention of qualified HVs, which was a national issue. It was coupled with increasing caseloads, increases in population, complexity of cases and level of need.

 

SWFT and WCC had co-developed a joint recovery/restoration plan in the Autumn of 2021. The report set out the short-term and longer-term actions proposed. The recovery plan was reviewed monthly involving service and commissioning leads, with oversight from the WCC Assistant Directors. A presentation was provided to highlight key messages from the report.

 

The following questions and comments were submitted, with responses provided as indicated:

 

  • The re-employment of retired HVs was discussed. Such people had vast experience and recently a retired HV had recommenced work in the Rugby area.
  • The value of nursery nurses was recognised, it being questioned how they could contribute to HV roles. It was also asked what WCC could do to assist. It was noted that some HV functions could not be undertaken by other personnel.
  • The recommendation was to note this report but there were concerns. Reference to the challenges observed at the Rugby Family Centre, specifically around HV caseloads. Also, the increasing complexity of cases identified at a body which determined grant funding applications. These included concerns around mental health and drug/alcohol issues. There was a national staffing shortfall in HVs. In the Rugby area a meeting to discuss the Joint Strategic Needs Assessment had included a number of aspects relevant to this discussion. However, there was no awareness of the concerns around the HV service, which showed the need within the system to better connect. Co-production was seen as a good way forward and it was about ‘how’ organisations could work together and enabling that to happen.
  • Another speaker echoed the points around how WCC and other organisations could help, focussing on recruitment aspects and making the  ...  view the full minutes text for item 3.

4.

Better Care Fund (BCF) Annual Plan 2022/23 pdf icon PDF 122 KB

The Board is asked to consider and provide feedback on the Better Care Fund Policy Framework and Planning Requirements for 2022/23, also to consider arrangements for the approval of the final submission to NHS England.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The Board considered a report on the Better Care Fund (BCF) submission and annual plan for 2022/23. The BCF was a programme spanning local government and the NHS which sought to join-up health and care services. The report set out key information on the BCF Policy Framework and the requirements for this year’s submission to NHS England by 26th September. Agreement was therefore sought for approval of the final version of the plan to be delegated to a Sub-Committee of the Board, once it had been approved by the Integrated Care Board and the County Council.

 

The report set out the four national conditions of the policy framework, along with additional system requirements for this year to agree high level capacity and demand plans for intermediate care services. It set out the compliance and other requirements for the local system. A section was provided on the future of the BCF policy framework. The financial implications detailed the grant funding to local government, which comprised the Improved Better Care Fund (iBCF) and Disabled Facilities Grant. Detail was provided on the financial contributions and mandatory funding sources, totalling just over £63million. Similar to previous years, the County Council continued as the pooled budget holder for the fund.

 

The report included supporting information on the metrics that must be included in BCF plans in 2022/23. It detailed the approvals already provided for this year’s BCF, those required prior to submission to NHS England and the future timetable for the BCF. Appended to the report were the BCF Narrative Plan, Planning Template and Capacity and Demand Plan.

 

Further information was provided around the completion of the sign-off processes, culminating in a meeting of the Board’s Sub-Committee on 22nd September at 2pm in Atherstone. The documents for that meeting would be published a week in advance showing tracked changes from those provided at this meeting.

 

Resolved

 

That Health and Wellbeing Board:

 

  1. Notes the Better Care Fund Policy Framework and Planning Requirements for 2022/23.

 

  1. Provides the feedback set out above on the draft Better Care Fund Narrative Plan, Planning Template and Capacity and Demand Plan for 2022/23 to ensure that these contribute to the wider Health and Wellbeing Board’s prevention priorities as well as meeting the BCF national conditions.

 

Agrees that the Board's Sub-Committee meets on 22nd September to approve the final version of the Better Care Fund Plan for 2022/23, for submission to NHS England.

5.

Pharmaceutical Needs Assessment pdf icon PDF 102 KB

One of the Board’s statutory duties is to produce and approve the Pharmaceutical Needs Assessment (PNA). The purpose of the PNA is to inform commissioners about the potential need for pharmacy-based services in an area.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Duncan Vernon and Michael Maddocks introduced a report and gave a presentation on the Coventry and Warwickshire Pharmaceutical Needs Assessment (PNA) 2022 – 2025. The purpose of the PNA was to assess local needs and identify gaps for pharmaceutical provision across Coventry and Warwickshire. It was a tool to enable the Health and Wellbeing Board to identify the current and future commissioning of services required from pharmaceutical service providers. A collaborative approach had been undertaken with Coventry. The PNA had undergone a period of formal consultation, which closed on 29th August and a verbal update was provided on the feedback received. Sections of the report provided background, and the minimum requirements for this process.

 

A copy of the PNA was included within the document pack. The accompanying presentation focussed on the service recommendations, overall recommendations and providing an update from consultation feedback. The key areas of feedback were:

 

  • Opening times for boots pharmacies
  • End of life medicines provision
  • Sharps disposal
  • Smoking cessation advanced service
  • References to CCG updated to ICB in the document
  • Additional note in appendices that pharmacies do not order or deliver scripts so any issues relating to that are beyond their control, and additional reflection on pharmacy pressures causing unplanned closures
  • Hypertension recommendation expanded
  • COVID-19 vaccination included (Phase 5)
  • Numbers added to a chart on pharmacies per 10,000 population

 

Questions and comments were submitted:

 

  • It was questioned if the PNA took account of anticipated population increases and whether the current pharmacies were in the correct locations. It was confirmed that there was adequate pharmacy provision now and there was the option to undertake a supplementary PNA, if required, following population growth.
  • Further information was sought about smoking cessation services. There were two commissioned offers, a new one from NHS England for patients discharged from hospital and a locally commissioned service for Warwickshire, which had recently been reviewed and recommissioned.
  • On drug and alcohol services, there was disparity across the County for example in the provision of needle disposal points. From feedback received it seemed that some pharmacies were not interested. The recommendation around sharps disposal was therefore welcomed.
  • A question on needle exchange points, whether they were in the correct locations and whether a mapping exercise should be undertaken.
  • On sharps bins, the numbers utilising the service was currently low, but it was hoped publicity and clarification of the service would increase uptake. An offer to seek more detailed feedback from the pharmaceutical steering group. For needle exchange, the core mapping had been undertaken and it appeared that adequate provision was made, but commissioners would keep this under review. The Chair requested a written update on the needle exchange and sharps disposal aspects.

 

Resolved

That Health and Wellbeing Board:

 

  1. Notes and comments upon the contents of the Pharmaceutical Needs Assessment (PNA) as set out above.

 

  1. Notes and comments as shown above upon the verbal update on consultation feedback.

 

Approves the publication of the PNA subject to any changes mentioned in the formal consultation verbal update.

6.

Healthwatch Warwickshire Annual Report pdf icon PDF 83 KB

The Health and Wellbeing Board is asked to consider the annual report of Healthwatch Warwickshire.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Liz Hancock (Chair) and Chris Bain (Chief Executive) of Healthwatch Warwickshire (HWW) presented its annual report for 2021/22. The annual report had been published in June 2022 and had been circulated widely.

 

It reported on service delivery in 2021/22, including a full range of services to the public. HWW had published ten reports relating to the improvements people would like to see to health and social care services. These were available on HWW’s website. In terms of future priorities, HWW would further develop its work to find out more about the lived experiences of people needing or using health and social care services. It planned to ensure that the lived experiences of seldom heard people and communities were properly considered. HWW would continue to engage positively with the Integrated Care System (ICS) at all levels to ensure that the voice of patients continued to be heard. It was already working proactively with various parts of the ICS. Similarly, it worked with colleagues in Healthwatch Coventry to ensure there was an effective service across the whole system. HWW was extending the focus of existing projects and developing new projects too. The accompanying presentation expanded on the key messages with Liz Hancock providing an overview and Chris Bain taking the Board through the detail of the annual report.

 

Councillor Falp commented that this agenda had included a lot of high-level strategic topics. This presentation showed how such strategies affected people and it was important for the Board to consider both aspects. The Chair agreed on the importance of hearing lived experience.

 

Resolved

That the Board notes the Healthwatch Warwickshire Annual Report.

7.

Serious Violence Prevention Strategy pdf icon PDF 124 KB

A discussion item which seeks the Board’s endorsement of a number of recommendations on the Serious Violence Prevention Strategy.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Jonathon Toy introduced this item which set out the duties for a number of partner agencies under the Police Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 to address the root causes of serious violence. These included requirements for collaboration and for consultation with education authorities and youth offending services in the preparation of a local Serious Violence Strategy.

 

The draft government guidance stated that the specified authorities come together to decide on the appropriate lead and structure of collaboration for their area. The government narrative had been referred to as a “Public Health Approach” to serious violence prevention.  Public Health England, in its publication, “A whole system multi agency approach to violence prevention”, set out three levels of violence prevention. Investment had been aligned to areas with high levels of serious violence. This was not applicable to Warwickshire, even though it was surrounded by areas which did meet the criteria and the County was a net importer of serious violence.

 

It was recognised that prevention was a key aspect. This required a long-term commitment by a range of agencies, individuals and communities. This approach would also support action towards health and wellbeing priorities.

 

Interventions to address serious violence were defined as universal (aimed at a general population); selected (targeted at those more at risk); and indicated (targeted at those who use violence). The Warwickshire Serious Violence Prevention Model was provided as an appendix to the report. It combined these universal and selected interventions, supporting those most impacted by serious violence, whilst creating a climate where serious violence was not tolerated.

 

The strategic priorities were reported, together with the requirements for consultation on the Strategy and the wide engagement undertaken with partner agencies. It had been adopted by the Safer Warwickshire Partnership Board (SWPB), the Education Authority, Youth Justice Service and National Probation Service. The next step was the development of a multi-agency delivery plan.

 

The SWPB would work with key stakeholders to maximise the resources available and influence partner organisations to deliver the Strategy. Detail was provided on the lead group to agree the priorities within the delivery plan and the training requirements for frontline practitioners.

 

In addition to the statutory duty, the Act had introduced serious weapon homicide reviews. For defined qualifying homicides review partners were required to conduct a review into the person’s death. Meeting this requirement was currently being worked through with the West Midlands Violence Reduction Unit.

 

The financial implications were reported. There were revenue implications of a partnership commissioning fund in the region of £100-150,000 per annum for a three-year period. It was expected this would be part-funded by the Home Office and the Office of the Police and Crime Commissioner had indicated a willingness to provide matched funding. The WCC Community Safety Team would take a lead role and there would be resource implications for all partners in regard to training and establishing the commissioning fund.

 

Questions and comments were submitted, with responses provided as indicated:

 

8.

Updates pdf icon PDF 94 KB

An update from each ‘Place’ on the progress made towards reducing inequalities in health and the wider determinants of health priority.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The Board received updates from each of the place-based

Health and Wellbeing Partnerships in Warwickshire. The Chair proposed that each partnership be invited to give an update by way of presentation at the January Board meeting.

9.

Levelling Up pdf icon PDF 107 KB

For the Board to consider the newly published countywide approach to levelling up in Warwickshire, and the opportunity for greater alignment and synergy between Levelling Up, health inequalities and the wider work of the Health & Wellbeing Strategy.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

This update concerned the newly published countywide approach to levelling up in Warwickshire and the opportunity for greater alignment and synergy between Levelling Up, health inequalities and the wider work of the Health & Wellbeing Strategy.

10.

Coventry and Warwickshire Integrated Health and Wellbeing Forum pdf icon PDF 190 KB

The Board is asked to consider the purpose and plans for the Integrated Health and Wellbeing Forum (formally the Place Forum).

Additional documents:

Minutes:

A report on proposals for the establishment of the Coventry and Warwickshire Integrated Health and Wellbeing Forum, which would replace the Coventry and Warwickshire Joint Place Forum. The new Forum would provide system leadership around the wider health and wellbeing agenda. As such it would contribute to achievement of the aims of the ICS, specifically tackling inequalities in outcomes, experience and access, and helping the NHS support broader social and economic development.

11.

Coventry and Warwickshire Population Health Management Roadmap pdf icon PDF 3 MB

An update on the Coventry and Warwickshire population health management road map.

Additional documents:

Minutes:

This report detailed the plans to improve population health through data-driven planning and delivery of proactive care. It sought to achieve this through use of analytical tools to identify local ‘at risk’ groups of people. It brought multi-disciplinary teams together to use these insights to design and target activity to prevent ill-health, improve health outcomes and reduce inequalities.

12.

Forward Plan pdf icon PDF 87 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

The Chair gave an outline of the agenda content for the January Board meeting. Nigel Minns suggested that an item be included to give early consideration of the Better Care Fund, which was agreed.